AutosarC++17_03-M5.2.11¶
The comma operator, && operator and the || operator shall not be overloaded
Required inputs: IR
| Level | required |
|---|---|
| Target | implementation |
| Enforcement | automated |
Rationale
Overloaded versions of the comma and logical conjunction operators have the semantics of function calls whose sequence point and ordering semantics are different from those of the built-in versions. It may not be clear at the point of use that these operators are overloaded, and so developers may be unaware which semantics apply.
Example
#include "util.h"
class A
{
public:
UtilType getValue ( );
UtilType setValue ( UtilType const & );
};
void f1 ( A & a1, A & a2 )
{
a1.getValue ( ) && a2.setValue ( 0 ); // Short circuiting may occur
} bool operator && ( UtilType const &,
UtilType const & ); // Non-compliant
void f2 ( A & a1, A & a2 )
{
a1.getValue ( ) && a2.setValue ( 0 ); // Both operands evaluated
}
If the type returned by getValue and setValue has an overloaded operator &&, then both getValue and setValue will be evaluated.
See also
ISO/IEC 14882:2003 §5.14, §5.15, §5.18
Note
For legal reasons, this rule’s description is not part of the public documentation.